Search |
||
Officially, I hate social networking (non Java rants)Posted by fabriziogiudici on February 15, 2008 at 3:42 AM PST
Well, I've just removed my account from FaceBook (for what I could do).
The reason? I've just run into this article by an italian newspaper about the incredibly unfriendly policy about privacy that FaceBook applies (*). Basically, it seems it's quite hard, if possible, to completely remove personal data from it. I find this frankly unbearable and I don't want to support a service with this policy. But there are really other reasons, and they are even more important. That episode just gave me the required five minutes to think of it (and blog on it during the lunch break). Basically, I didn't explicitly subscribed to FaceBook - I just accepted the invitation by a friend without understanding what was happening - a very subtle viral trick by those social networking sites. Indeed, the following things hold true:
(*) What drives me crazy is that when the public authority places a new camera down in the square or asks you for more information before an international flight, people raise up and protest against the Big Brother, the CIA, the NSA, and - of course - Mr. Bush or the local equivalent. Yes, freedom is always at stake, you have to constantly fight for it, maybe all those things are not so useful for the security purpose, but at least there's a sound reason behind it, which is not to be killed by a terrorist. In the meantime everybody is happy to give away the size of his pants to a site such as FaceBook without worrying about it. And, after all, only a few people are complaining about the absurd privacy policy of FaceBook. Which, BTW, sounds to be illegal in my country. In Italy there are some strict rules about personal data management and I remember that, when I run for a few years as the person in charge for the database of an association, it was one of my duties to amend and eventually completely remove the personal record upon the owner's request, and I had to do that in a pretty tight deadline... (**) Yeah, yeah, I know that big money is on that business. Nevetheless, it's not my fault if people like to waste money, and it's neither a new thing indeed (for instance, people have always spent more money and time on things such as cigarettes, watching movies, attending football matches or dancing in a disco rather than buying and reading books). »
Comments
Comments are listed in date ascending order (oldest first)
Submitted by andreamoz on Mon, 2008-02-18 08:07.
Pretty much agree with everything. I would not be so unconditional to address everything else but books as a waste of money; e.g. last year I enjojed very much watching the Italian rugby final.
Besides, networks like LinkedIn can be an opportunity, but that's a whole different story as they're very business oriented.
Submitted by fabriziogiudici on Mon, 2008-02-18 15:47.
Well, rugby is a different beast than football (at least until masses get fanatic about it and spoil it). Also LinkedIn is a different beast than FaceBook, in fact I'm still subscribed to LinkedIn and I appreciate it as valuable service.
For the rest, yes, FaceBook it's (just) not for me. Of course, quot capita, tot sententiae. :-) And I'm amazed too that it got to the front page.
Submitted by gturek on Mon, 2008-02-18 17:36.
E bravo! Finalmente uno che la pensa come me :-)
Ciao!
Submitted by bainfu on Mon, 2008-02-18 11:11.
Ever think maybe Facebook is not for you? Some people enjoy Lifecasting and these Social networks are a way for there lives to stay connected with friends (without the traditional human interaction). Not saying this is the right way to do things, but it is a way.
But I love the fact that this ended up to be on the front page of Java.net. (sarcastic comment)
Submitted by jwenting on Tue, 2008-02-19 01:40.
Well said Fabrizio. And indeed, the "privacy" policies of Facebook (and Hyves, and most other "social networking sites") would not pass the requirements the EU places on companies (or government departments, though those happily break them with no penalty). In fact a lot of websites don't abide by those rules, including for example Google (and all their subsidiaries including gmail).
Submitted by hte on Tue, 2008-02-19 02:10.
Hi Fabrizio,
You write: "What drives me crazy is that when the public authority places a new camera down in the square or asks you for more information before an international flight, people raise up and protest against the Big Brother, the CIA, the NSA, and - of course - Mr. Bush or the local equivalent." Well said! I agree completely. I recommend everyone to take 4½ minute to watch this brilliant animation film about what can happen if we don't fight for our freedom.
Submitted by willfarnaby on Sat, 2008-03-22 17:42.
Facebook (and PayPal and eBay and...) apparently are associated with right wing extremists, the loathsome type that forms the coercive, warped cabal forcing this beautiful planet backwards and downwards to oblivion.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/jan/14/facebook
Submitted by evanx on Tue, 2008-05-06 11:04.
i think the idea of social networking, which is certainly not mature yet given its young age, is valid. I think it's about going beyond generalised email and IM and bookmarking/media-sharing sites (in this big messy spam-filled cloud we call the web) and effectively integrating all of the above into a private and convenient messaging/communications/sharing platform, which is controlled by yourself, exclusive, spam-free and what-not?
|
||
|
|