Skip to main content

Poll Result: New Is Better, But Still Needs Improvement

Posted by editor on June 21, 2011 at 10:32 PM PDT

The results of the last poll indicate that the community in general considers the new to be better than the previous edition of the site -- but further improvement in many areas is still needed. The poll was designed to be a forum through which the community could provide feedback on the changes to that were implemented starting in late February. A total of 96 votes were cast, and a valuable conversation was carried on in 15 posted comments.

The actual question and voting results were:

Now that you're accustomed to it, what do you think of the new

  • 20% (19 votes) - It's much improved
  • 45% (43 votes) - It's better, but some areas still need improvement
  • 9% (9 votes) - I about the same as I did before
  • 19% (18 votes) - The old site was better
  • 3% (3 votes) - I don't know
  • 4% (4 votes) - Other

For, this is a very positive set of numbers (65% consider the site to be improved compared with its previous edition). At the same time, it's clear that most people who chose to vote believe could be better. The posted comments emphasize this by pointing out several problem areas, and pointing out the seriousness of the site's deficiencies.

For example, wadechandler, in a thoughtful and detailed comment, said:

I think whoever is working on needs to seriously check out and I find to be quite "anti-social" with its anemic feature set. Heck, I'm honestly trying to use it out of loyalty and all, but it is pretty frustrating in some areas, and I'm debating going back to SourceForge for my own projects because who has time to waste.

One of the problems with is the lack of documentation for the users. For example, Wade asked "How do I contact and arbitrary user of So, I know their name and their user name, and I want to send them a message..."

It's actually quite easy to accomplish this on, because sending an email to automatically forwards the message to that user. But, only a few people know this. In addition, the performance of email initiated through addresses has often been poor (including project email lists). The performance problems are being addressed. But, if you'd like to contact an arbitrary user, and you send an email to, you can be pretty certain that your message will get through, ultimately. really could use a User's Guide of some sort, whether a wiki, or a java-net-doc project, or something like that. The team is aware of our documentation deficit -- but, reading the comments posted to this poll makes me think this is a more serious problem than I had considered it to be before now.

New poll: JavaFX 2.0 Beta

Our new poll asks "Do you intend to experiment with the JavaFX 2.0 Beta Release?" Voting will be open until this Friday, June 24. Weblogs

Since my last blog post (New Article: Reducing Contention and Overhead in Worker Queues), the following blogs have been published by other bloggers:


Our latest article is "A Method for Reducing Contention and Overhead in Worker Queues for Multithreaded Java Applications", by Sathiskumar Palaniappan, Kavitha Varadarajan, and Jayashree Viswanathan.

Java News

Here are the stories we've recently featured in our Java news section:


Our latest href="">Spotlight is Yolande Poirier's Java and Parallelism Computing: An Interview with Java Developer and Researcher Dr. Gilda Garretón:

Electric VLSI Design System is an open source VLSI CAD application used as a research platform for new CAD algorithms as well as the research flow for hardware test chips. Worldwide, Electric is used in academia and small industry. The CAD applications are time-consuming tools applied to very large data sets (circuit designs). With those important characteristics, plus the fact that Electric is fully implemented in Java, this framework has been the perfect environment to apply cutting edge parallel techniques on multicore processors in Java...

We're also featuring Java Spotlight Episode 34: Chuck Munn Lee on Using PhoneME on Nintendo DS:

Interview with Chuck Mun Lee, Java Evangelist, on porting PhoneME to Nintendo DS. Joining us this week on the Java All Star Developer Panel are Dalibor Topic, Java Free and Open Source Software Ambassador, and Alexis Moussine-Pouchkine, Java EE Developer Advocate...

Subscriptions and Archives: You can subscribe to this blog using the Editor's Blog Feed. You can also subscribe to the Java Today RSS feed and the blogs feed. You can find historical archives of what has appeared the front page of in the home page archive.

-- Kevin Farnham

Twitter: @kevin_farnham