Skip to main content

Gut feel

Posted by daniel on January 6, 2005 at 8:46 AM PST

What do you believe is true?

The World Question Center has asked scientists and science minded
people What do you
believe is true even though you can't prove it
. As Alan Kay
writes in his answer, "Guessing in science is done all the time, and
the difference between what is real and what is true is not a big
factor in the guessing stage, but makes all the difference
epistemologically later in the process."

Kay's answer talks about the guess he "made in 1966 about objects
not that one could build everything from objects that could be proved
mathematically but that using objects would be a much better way to
represent most things. This is not very provable, but like the
Internet, now has quite a body of evidence that suggests this was a
good guess. Another guess [..] is that what is special about the
computer is analogous to and an advance on what was special about
writing and then printing. It's not about automating past forms that
has the big impact, but as McLuhan pointed out, when you are able to
change the nature of representation and argumentation, those who learn
these new ways will wind up to be qualtitatively different and better
thinkers, and this will (usually) help advance our limited conceptions
of civilization."

Check out the answers from the 120 people surveyed. Esther Dyson
answers " I think modern life has fundamentally and paradoxically
changed our sense of time. Even as we live longer, we seem to think
shorter. Is it because we cram more into each hour? Or because the
next person over seems to cram more into each hour?"

Mathematician
Keith Devlin answered "following Descartes, I can prove to myself that
I exist, but I can't prove it to anyone else. Even to those who know
me well there is always the possibility, however remote, that I am
merely a figment of their imagination." As a recovering Mathematician,
I think that Devlin has demonstrated something I know but can not
prove: when you pose a perfectly reasonable question to a
Mathematician they will tend to frame a response that is correct but
responds to a question that interests them more than the one they were
posed. After arguing "that proof is, in practical terms, an
unachievable ideal," he concludes "you have to take a common sense
approach to proof—in this case proof being, I suppose, an argument
that would convince the intelligent, professionally skeptical, trained
expert in the appropriate field."

Add your thoughts about what you believe is true in the talkback below.


Also featured in href="http://today.java.net/today/alsotoday.csp"> Also in Java
Today
, Tim O'Brien says "If you are not familiar with the href="http://jakarta.apache.org/commons">Jakarta Commons you have
likely reinvented a few wheels. Before you write any more generic
frameworks or utilities, grok the Commons. It will save you serious
time." In his article href="http://www.onjava.com/pub/a/onjava/2004/12/22/jakarta-gems-1.html">The
Hidden Gems of Jakarta Commons, Part 1, he exposes some
interesting and little noticed helpers in the commons, including more
efficient means of parsing XML files with Digester, functors (like
predicates, closures, and transformers) in the commons collections,
and using XPath to query objects and collections.


Eduardo Pelegri-Llopart writes about href="http://weblogs.java.net/blog/pelegri/archive/2005/01/start_using_bin.html">
The FI Project - An Open Source Implementation of a Binary XML
Standard in today's href="http://weblogs.java.net/"> Weblogs. He reports " Sun
has released under Open Source its implementation of Fast Infoset, an
in-progress standard for Binary XML. Fast Infoset is simple to use and
to integrate; you can think of it as GZIP for XML. This implementation
is intended to be a high quality implementation to be used in
production artifacts and we hope it will encourage wide adoption of
the standard."

Ken Ramirez blogs about his new Portlet tip. In href="http://weblogs.java.net/blog/ken_ramirez/archive/2005/01/this_months_tip.html">
This month's tip Ken points out that "Although this month's tip is
entitled, 'Internalizing Your Portlets', you can use resource bundles
for non-internalized portlets."

Jonathan Simon shares an adventure with how easily word meanings
can get hijacked in href="http://weblogs.java.net/blog/jonathansimon/archive/2005/01/refactoring_can.html">
Refactoring can be a dangerous word. His tale shows how
refactoring came to mean rewriting.


In today's href="http://forums.java.net/jive/index.jspa">
Forums, Eduardo launches the new Binary Web Services and
XML forum
saying "The Forum is intended to cover any and all topics
regarding binary XML and binary WS, regardless of the implementation
language (Java or not), and of whether the implementation project is
at Java.Net or not."


In Projects and
Communities
, Ken Ramirez has published the tip href="https://www.dev.java.net/files/documents/1654/10299/tip3.html">Portlet
Resource Bundles on Internationalizing your portlets in the
java.net Portlet
community.

The Java Web
Services and XML
community has launched a new forum for
discussing href="http://forums.java.net/jive/forum.jspa?forumID=44"> Binary Web
Services and XML.


In today's java.net
News Headlines
:

Registered users can submit news items for the href="http://today.java.net/today/news/">java.net News Page using
our news submission
form
. All submissions go through an editorial review before being
posted to the site. You can also subscribe to the href="http://today.java.net/pub/q/news_rss?x-ver=1.0">java.net News
RSS feed.


Archives and Subscriptions: This blog is delivered
weekdays as the href="http://today.java.net/pub/q/java_today_rss?x-ver=1.0">Java
Today RSS feed. Also, once this page is no longer featured
as the front page of java.net
it will be archived along with other past issues in the href="http://today.java.net/today/archive/">java.net
Archive.

What do you believe is true?