Skip to main content

Is Java popular in spite of its standards?

Posted by johnreynolds on April 19, 2004 at 2:30 PM PDT

Mention JSPs positively in a blog and you will undoubtably get flamed. Encourage colleagues to use Entity Beans and you may never be taken seriously again. JDO was crippled for many by the lack of a standard for O/R mapping. EJBQL, and JDOQL lacked the functionality that many legacy RDBMS schemas demanded.

These are just a few of the "standard" features of Java that are reviled by ardent Java supporters... but for some reason developers stay loyal.

Are we loyal because we fear domination by Microsoft? Judging by the paranoid reactions of many to the Microsoft-Sun cease fire there's probably some truth to that conjecture.

Are we loyal because we ignore "standards"? Ignore might too mild a term, armed resistance might be more accurate. From the very beginning we've engaged in civil disobediance, rolling our own solutions and banding together to support projects that openly challenge the wisdom of the "standards". For every Jakarta project that implements a JCP standard, there's at least one that opposes the same standard.

So what should we make of all this?

I'm not sure myself, but I do think that the "major" players need to take notice and adjust their approaches. The user community does not respond to edicts from "on high", and doesn't care how much money has been spent to push a feature. In the egalitarian world where anyone can post an opinion the best laid plans of corporate marketeers aren't worth much. Bad solutions may linger, but they'll never prosper.

At this particular time, we're at a crossroads. The major players are either working on tools to hide the ugly guts (BEA's Weblogic Workshop's Controls), distract us with shiny new window dressings (Sun Creator Studio's Java Server Faces), or decouple the whole model (JBoss's AOP/Hibernate). All agree that creating a J2EE application is difficult and error prone, and all are scrambling for a fix.

Let's hope the result isn't another set of standards that developers love to hate.

Related Topics >>