Killer Applications and JXTA
Serial Killer Applications
Some technologies don't gain wide adoption until there is an application used by a large number of users. We call them killer applications because they are so compelling or in fact kill a problem dead. For the personal computer it was the spreadsheet (Visicalc was the first and it was copied by the rest) and at about the same time, the word processor. What will be the killer application for JXTA? Is it already here?
P2P & File Sharing - Capture and Death of a Serial Killer
Napster was a killer application. Sadly it was done in a way that was not legal. I won't go into the politics of record companies and free speech - the fact is that Napster was taken out of play by the courts. Yes there are other music sharing and purchasing applications, but nothing as big as Napster. But the other problem is that it was only about music (at least the killer part). There was no real big application associated with general business or entertainment based on the P2P/Central-Index scheme of Napster.
Don't think that there are not other file sharing applications doing quite well. In fact, there are file sharing applications written in JXTA that support thousands of users in legitimate business applications. They may become the new 'next big thing' but I see it as just a better way to share files rather than the ultimate killer application.
People Like to Save Time and Effort
Sometimes a killer application just makes things easier. Struts is making it even easier to develop web applications. Ant makes it easier to build and maintain projects. XDoclets reduces labor via its code generation capabilities. All these examples are starting to be widely adopted because of their productivity improvements.
Can JXTA make things easier?
JXTA has all the hallmarks of reduced effort. First, there is no real server involved. Imagine the time, money, and sweat equity saved by not dealing with the monolithic server and its support system. But that's just economics - where is the savings for the common man? Let's look a little at one of the key ideas about JXTA.
It's a Candy / It's a Breath Mint
What makes JXTA unique? It's not about Peer-to-Peer (P2P). P2P is just a fuzzy buzzword that means computers talking to to computers. What abut JXTA is that it places the Internet inside applications rather than the browser. This also means the gestalt of the application includes a real interface, storage, and can be run 24 hours a day if needed.
The quote below is from Juan Taylor, which covers this quite nicely:
What s the ONE thing that P2P can do that client/server can't?
It's that the Client can be a Server.
WHY would the client want to be a server?
To share information Easily and in different and even
complex (only jxta can do this) ways in a 'User to
User' way. In anonymous file-sharing there is an
innate loss of wanting to share files. In a User to
User perspective, there is an immediate desire to
There's the Benefit, and the complexity of which only JXTA can handle.
What this means simply is that unlike client server, JXTA is client/server and server/client or even server to server or client to client. The information, storage, processing, and communications can start at either end. In the world of applications this also means that I don't have to work in a world of centralized resources where there are multiple issues. The worst problem of course is just the impedance mismatch between the world of application and the world of web applications.
Are You Thinking Differently?
So, what if every client was a server? Sadly it is not all about efficiency. I say sadly because P2P is all about wasted space and CPU cycles. The sad part is the knee jerk reaction many have to waste. But the fact is that replicating data and the power of your own CPU verses a shared server is far safer and can be orders of magnitude more efficient in getting the job done. The waste is insignificant in terms of the modern PC with their large disks and often idle CPU's. When you trade inefficiency in an area that is monetarily insignificant, the gain in productivity is essentially for free.
The forum interface is similar to those on Java.net. Basically a forum is a threaded discussion. The oldest version of this is the old news forums which still exists but has been taken over by spam. Think of it as a server based email that anyone can read or submit messages.
What would a P2P Forum look like? First the history of the messages need to be available to anyone. This a great feature of the forum because it lets you search for a conversation in the past. Guess what, that has to be on a PC since there is no server. Here comes the duplication of effort: To make this work, keeping the history on as many computers as possible increases the speed of the search. The search is really fast if you have your own copy. If the forum history is very large, and is bigger than that free 5 gigabytes on your disk, we can share different sections of the data. We still need a lot of copies because some peers may go off line.
Thinking until it Hurts
Ok, does it hurt your sense of efficient computing yet? I remember being unable to use linked lists and hash tables for years because my professor in college was so anal that memory was the most important thing in the world. He put speed and ease of use far far down the list of importance.
Waste or efficient use?
Ok, now back to killer applications. What if we added a P2P forum to a development tool? First, because it is part of the tools, the focus is like a laser. The efficiency of use is very close to the tool because it is the tool. Have a weird exception? It is a click to add it verses cut and paste and a little reformatting. Wondering what the correct settings are for a task? What if the expert could reply with his settings which you can just use rather than interpret a poorly formatted and worded answer. Yes I have perhaps a couple gig of messages, but I have the world's greatest integrated help system. These ideas are Copyright Daniel Brookshier 2004, all rights and derivative patents can not be used by Microsoft or its agents. Free use to those that use 100% Java and JXTA to implement the solution. Ideas like this need to be free to make life less like walking on broken glass.
JXTA is a killer capability that will make a good application a great application. Making every a PC a server seems like a good idea. Not every solution will benefit, but there are a few thousand new ideas that JXTA makes possible. Look at the world upside down. Be the server.