Skip to main content

Poll Result: OpenJDK, GlassFish Considered the Most Important java.net Projects

Posted by editor on January 29, 2010 at 12:54 PM PST

This past week's java.net poll indicates that two of the biggest java.net projects, OpenJDK and GlassFish, are considered most important among all java.net projects, as we head into the future. A total of 416 votes were cast. The exact question and results were:

What's the most important java.net project going forward?

  • 29% (119 votes) - GlassFish
  • 8% (34 votes) - Hudson
  • 0% (2 votes) - OpenDS
  • 2% (9 votes) - OpenSSO
  • 51% (211 votes) - OpenJDK
  • 2% (10 votes) - Other
  • 7% (31 votes) - I don't know

There were two comments posted to the poll. When I saw the first comment, "Unfair Poll", which was posted by suhail, I wondered if the poll was in some way offensive, and if I should close it. Here's suhail's comment:

I think this poll is quite unfair. Because I actively use first five of the choices in various projects and each of them have their own community if you follow the mailing list. Since their in zero overlap between the choices, in essence what you are doing is performing a poll on the developers involved. And i find it quite hard to believe that you didn't already know that the JDK project would be your number one project

After reading this comment many times, and thinking about it, I decided it was OK to let the poll continue. I don't think that the only people who vote in a poll like this are necessarily participants in one or more of the project communities. So, I don't think that the vote totals for each project will be directly correlated with the number of developers who work on each project (if that's what suhail was implying). One can be an avid user of Hudson and think it is a great tool, and not use GlassFish at all -- but still think GlassFish is overall a more important project going forward.

I, like suhail, guessed that OpenJDK would probably win the most votes. However, I don't know that I would have selected OpenJDK myself, had I voted. Java is a quite mature language, with an enormous installed base. In terms of importance for the future, how much of a difference will the next set of JDK enhancements make for Java developers? Are the changes that are being worked on for the Java language itself likely to be more world-changing in the next five years than the emergence of GlassFish as both the Java EE 6 reference implementation and the Oracle-supported application server for smaller installations? And what about Hudson? Might it become the focus point for a revolution in software engineering, and beyond that, diversified process automation and control (for example, Hudson can monitor cron jobs)?

In the other comment, nathanlee asked "Netbeans?" and said "Anything and everything netbeans is my vote.. Then glassfish." Well, I certainly agree that NetBeans is an important project, and, as with GlassFish, Oracle has stated that NetBeans will continue to be supported (as a lightweight IDE with a focus on Java EE, Java ME, scripting, and mobile development). However, the NetBeans project is not hosted on java.net (though we do have a java.net NetBeans Community). So, that's why NetBeans wasn't one of the poll options.

By the way, every project in the poll has been cited by Oracle for continued support going forward. So, you could say that Oracle has "voted" for all the poll options.

New poll: your java.net participation

Our new java.net poll asks In what ways do you participate in the java.net community? Voting will be open for the next week.


In Java Today, Dustin Marx provides comments and overview in Oracle/Sun: The Deal Has Closed page:

"Oracle has finalized the Sun transaction and the deal has closed." The above statement can be found on the Sun and Oracle: Overview and Frequently Asked Questions for the Developer Community page. Besides this simple but definitive statement, the page includes some answers to some of the early questions Java developers might have about Java under Oracle. Questions asked cover subjects such as Sun's Java development network pages, Java.net, future of JavaOne, and more...

Arun Gupta highlights the GlassFish strategy by Oracle+Sun:

Hear Hasan Rizvi, Senior Vice President, Oracle Fusion Middleware, talk about GlassFish in Oracle and Sun Application Server Strategy webcast. The first part of the webcast is about the overall strategy and then the GlassFish part starts around 5:23 in the video...

Geertjan Wielenga thinks Wouldn't it have been cool if Oracle had said... :

Wouldn't it have been cool if Oracle had said the following, sometime during all those announcements yesterday: "The NetBeans Platform is very important to a lot of our customers, who are actually building their products on top of the NetBeans Platform. We want to make that the best platform that we can for doing that for you." If Oracle had said that...


In today's Weblogs, Markus Karg is happy to have Finished my new web site:

So finally, after endless nights, my new web site Head Crashing Informatics is finished. Learned a lot on XHTML and CSS by coding it completely by hand (yes, really, did not use any design tool, as I love to code and always want to see what's going on behind the scenes). In the future you'll find my latest stuff there, research results, code snippets, background information on my projects, and certainly my products (like Database Schema Viewer). Btw, even I am not a professional designer, I think my new web site looks much better than the new Sun -sorry- Oracle web site...

Jan Haderka writes about Multi-site support in Magnolia:

Yet another week of development is nearly over (at least for me). What was this week all about? Apart from the really low temperatures outside (on Tuesday it was -24C at 4am), I focused mainly on extending the multi-site support in Magnolia. This feature exists for years already. But what it really means in context of Magnolia? In general you can setup the server to run mulptiple domains and you can configure such server to redirect to different subtree respective to what domain was the incoming traffic directed. The Magnolia part of the multi-site support allows you to assign different site (and theme) to each such subtree...

Joerg Plewe talks about Bundle-Bee - transparent, grid-distributed OSGi computing:

In my famous company innoQ I currently have the opportunity to work on a real cool tool: Bundle-Bee. It claims to be able to take any OSGi bundle and distribute the computational load to an ad-hoc grid (e.g. all machines in an office) without special setup or configuration.

We just released version 0.5.3 which is still very restricted and far from feature complete - we don't even know what feature completeness might mean - but is already quite useful when it comes to doing computationally intensive things. Like fractals...


In the Forums, samlclient_user has a Metro/JAXB Issue with Validating Reference in signed SAML assertion: I've created a SAML 1.1 assertion using the SAMLAssertionFactory in the package com.sun.xml.wss.saml. Then I use the Assertion class's sign method to sign the assertion. On the server side, when it tries to verify the message, it cannot validate the Reference inside the SAML assertion. The problem is that the digest value's don't match...

eduardomartins announces Mobicents JAIN SLEE 2.0.0.CR1 released!: Hi everyone, "just" announcing the release of Mobicents JAIN-SLEE 2.0.0.CR1, the candidate release of the second generation Mobicents JAIN SLEE container, compliant with JAIN SLEE 1.1 specification, and built on top of JBoss AS 5.1.0.GA. This release took longer than expected, due to extensive testing done by the team, but we couldn't be more happier with the results, we are very confident it won't need another CR release and will make the first GA available in 2 weeks...

In the GlassFish WebTier forum, nzinoviev has questions on JSF 2.0.3 and composite attributes "required" validation: Hi! Yesterday we tried switching from JSF 2.0.2 snapshot to 2.0.3. We ran into several issues, here's the most unexpected one: I have declaration...


Our current Spotlight is Janice Heiss's interview with Java Champion Adam Bien on JavaFX. Adam's opening statement: "Good UI controls and layout are the key to success. JavaFX was very strong from the beginning in effects and graphics. It was, however, initially lacking in good, "skinnable" components, but this was fixed with version 1.2. JavaFX requires writing less code while it integrates very well with existing business logic written in Java. A reason to go the JavaFX route is better maintainability, and faster development with less code..."


This week's java.net Poll asks In what ways do you participate in the java.net community? Voting will be open through the end of next week.


We've just published a new java.net Feature Article, Maven Repository Managers for the Enterprise, by John Smart. We're also featuring Jeff Friesen's Reading Newsfeeds in JavaFX with FeedRead, in which Jeff demonstrates how to apply JavaFX's RSS and Atom newsfeed capabilities to create a snazzy little JavaFX app that can run stand-alone or in a browser.


The latest Java Mobility Podcast is Java Mobile Podcast 92: MIDP 3.0 in Depth: Tutorials and Demonstrations: Excerpts from the JavaOne 2009 MIDP 3.0 In Depth: Tutorials and Demonstrations session with Roger Riggs, Lakshmi Dontamsetti and Stan Kao.


Current and upcoming Java Events:

Registered users can submit event listings for the java.net Events Page using our events submission form. All submissions go through an editorial review before being posted to the site.


Archives and Subscriptions: This blog is delivered weekdays as the Java Today RSS feed. Also, once this page is no longer featured as the front page of java.net it will be archived along with other past issues in the java.net Archive.

-- Kevin Farnham

O'Reilly Media
Twitter: @kevin_farnham