Skip to main content

This Week's Poll: Is the JCP an Independent Standards Organization?

Posted by editor on November 9, 2010 at 10:34 PM PST

The JCP has pretty much never not been a topic of considerable discussion among Java developers. I mean, even if we don't think about the Java Community Process every day, almost all of us have interest in particular JSRs. And so, throughout its history, a lot has been said and written about the JCP -- and not only at election time.

With the acquisition of Sun by Oracle, the JCP has come into sharp focus once again. That this could happen seems a bit strange, if we think of the JCP as a Java standards organization. Why would a corporate acquisition affect a standards organization?

Yet, in my 30+ years of being in the software engineering field, what I have observed with respect to software standards bodies is that they are indeed highly affected by corporate presences. Which makes sense since the corporations that utilize the technologies have the money and provide the support that grows the technologies in new directions.

At the same time, this can turn supposedly objective standards bodies into political arenas where vendors fight to standardize features that provide their products with an advantage in the marketplace.

Anyway, this week's poll asks you to provide your opinion on the JCP. Specifically, we're asking: Is the JCP an independent standards organization?

Voting will be open until this coming Monday.

Java Today

Terrence Barr is Podcasting again! The new “Java Spotlight” Podcast:

After a bit of a hiatus from the 92 episodes of the Java Mobility Podcast, Roger Brinkley and I are back at it again! And as part of the broader Java Evangelism team at Oracle we’re upleveling the scope of the podcast to encompass the whole breath of Java, including Java EE, SE, ME, JavaFX, and more. We’re keeping the popular format of the show – news, a feature segment or interview, and...

Markus Eisele provides Mobile Apps - Native? Flash? HTML 5? - a decision helper:

Playing around with mobile app development recently one question comes up over and over again: Should I write a native app, rely on the browser capabilities or even take the flash/air approach? As you might have guessed, this is not an easy answer...

Kohsuke Kawaguchi announces that InfraDNA joins forces with CloudBees:

Today, I’m happy to announce that InfraDNA is joining forces with CloudBees (there’s also a press release that’s far better written than my post.) In the past 6 months, I think InfraDNA made a lot of progress. Hudson kept getting better, which in turn resulted in a continued growth of the adoption. We are also working with a number of vendors, such as CollabNet and Sauce Labs...

Lincoln Baxter III describes How to: Use CDI with JSF 2 PhaseListeners – Explained:

A recent thread came up on the JSF 2 forums: “ href="">Why can’t I use @Inject in a PhaseListener? This CDI stuff is so confusing.”FIrst, before I start explaining: this is possible, but there’s a little background you should probably know. The answer to the question “why can’t I use CDI in JSF PhaseListeners?” is: because JSF 2 was completed just a few short months before JSR-299 and the rest of the title="Java" href="" >Java EE 6 platform specifications were finalized...


Our latest Spotlight is Steven Haines's DeveloperWorks article 5 things you didn't know about ... multithreaded programming:

Multithreaded programming is never easy, but it does help to understand how the JVM processes subtly different code constructs. Steven Haines shares five tips that will help you make more informed decisions when working with synchronized methods, volatile variables, and atomic classes...

We're also featuring Java Spotlight Podcast 2: Steve Harris - Senior VP of Application Server Development -

Interview with Steve Harris, Senior VP of Application Server Development on the Java Enterprise Edition, Glassfish, and integrating Sun into Oracle. Joining us this week on the Java All Star Developer Panel are Dalibor Topic, Java free and open source software ambassador, and Alexis Moussine-Pouchkine, Java EE Evangelist...


Our current poll asks Is the JCP an independent standards organization? Voting will be open until Monday.

Subscriptions and Archives: You can subscribe to this blog using the Editor's Blog Feed. You can also subscribe to the Java Today RSS feed and the blogs feed. You can find historical archives of what has appeared the front page of in the home page archive.

-- Kevin Farnham

Twitter: @kevin_farnham


This Week's Poll: Is the JCP

Thanks for the post. This information is very useful for me as I just start to learn about blog commenting.
chau rua | bon rua | chau rua chen | bon rua chen